The cakes look good, right? However, they did not eat the cakes.... I guess they like a meaty taste more than cakes. I was kind of shocked that they did not eat the cakes so I did not make anything this year. In stead, I bought some Greenies for them because they love it. They are now 6 years old. I just hope they will live healthy and long long time! Happy birthday, Milo and Murphy!